Police Use of Social Media Expanding & It’s Raising New Concerns
By Jim DeFede
During the mayhem of last month’s “Wheels Up, Guns Down” biker protests, a rider used his cellphone to document his escape from Hollywood police. Laughing throughout the video, the rider must have seen this as a real achievement later proudly posted it on Instagram so his friends view his triumph.
Unfortunately, it wasn’t just his friends who saw the post. One of the officers chasing him noticed he was taking video and searched social media. Once he found it he was able to identify the rider as Wilfredo Garcia of New York. A warrant was issued and the NYPD picked up Garcia and extradited him to Broward.
“Social media has become a new tool for law enforcement as people like to brag about crimes that they are doing,” noted Hollywood Police Chief Tomas Sanchez.
In 2015, the International Association of Chiefs of Police conducted a survey of more than 400 police agencies and found that 96% percent of them used social media in some capacity, including over half for listening or monitoring and three-quarters for intelligence gathering purposes.
“You’d be surprised how easy sometimes it is because these bad guys go on those venues to show off what they’ve done, what they did,” said Major Jorge Martin, who oversees the Miami Police Department’s Special Investigations Section. “They want to tell their friends. They want to show the goods, literally.”
Martin’s analysts and detectives tap into social media as part of gang and narcotics investigations. In one instance, a drug dealer showed all of the hundred dollars bills he received in a drug deal. What he didn’t realize was that before making the deal with undercover officers, they had written down all of the serial numbers and police now had additional proof he had the money.
Martin took CBS4 News into a restricted area on the second floor of police headquarters. It was a rare look behind the scenes as most police agencies are reluctant to show this side of their operation. Even Martin was hesitant.
“I don’t want to be the one that gives that trade secret away,” he said. But, he admitted, “I’d be less than truthful to you or to the viewing public to tell you that we don’t incorporate the use of social media to help us – absolutely. There are just different ways that we do things, there are different guidelines that we have to abide by.”
While most of what police do involves open sources that just about anyone can easily see or read, there are high-tech security companies like Geofeedia and Snaptrends that market their services to police departments across the country with technology that some believe cross the line into spying.
The technology is so advanced it allows police to focus their lenses on an entire city or drill down to a neighborhood or even a city block to examine Twitter, Instagram and Facebook posts in that area. CBS4 News has learned the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, and a half a dozen departments in South Florida use Snaptrends, including the City of Miami.
“I’ll say it’s within the tool box – an item that we use like Facebook and everything else,” Martin said. “It’s an evolving technology.”
Asked if he worried about the Big Brother aspect to all of this technology, he replied, “Me, myself, no. I personally would want all of the investigative advantages I could get. The bad guys I’m going after may want to worry about it, but for me, bring on the technology.”
It’s not just criminal activity. Social media is being used by police to anticipate demonstrations and track protesters and protest leaders.
“It’s just to make sure it is an orderly event that we want to get numbers on because that’s a public safety concern,” he said.
Late last year, the ACLU and the Brennan Center for Social Justice issued reports questioning the use of Snaptrends and Geofeedia by police. As a result, Twitter and Facebook are now blocking those companies from accessing their information, rendering them largely useless to police. But other companies may take their place, which means these issues are not going away.
- More than 20 candidates apply for Miami Gardens police chief job
- No more ‘gun-free zones’ in Florida? Lawmakers float plan to end them
- Coconut Grove church will mark birthday with wedding celebration.. (MPD vet Ray Martinez)
- Two cities look to tackle prostitution and drug dealing along Calle Ocho
- Miami's Independent Police Oversight Board Fights for Its Right to Investigate Rogue Cops
- At MIA, there’s economy, first class and ... politician. Officials’ travel perks under fire.
- Ex-Miami Dade cop convicted of stealing from drivers during traffic stops
- K-9 officer injured, shooter found dead in vacant Miami Shores home
- Break-in at MPD vehicle impound lot could imperil dozens of criminal cases
- Florida businesses that ban guns could be held liable for leaving patrons defenseless
- Protesters rally against Mayor Gimenez’s immigration policy in Downtown Miami
- Miami Beach Police fight to install license plate readers on all state roads
- 1 killed, 3 hospitalized in fiery Miami-Dade crash involving stolen police car
- Regalado: City of Miami ‘will not comply’ with ‘sanctuary city’ order
- Anger erupts in Miami-Dade after mayor abandons ‘sanctuary’ policy
- Miami takes step toward replacing moldy police headquarters
- Miami-Dade mayor orders jails to comply with Trump crackdown on ‘sanctuary’ counties
- Federal police monitor: Miami ‘committed’ to Justice agreement
- Anti-Trump protesters march in Downtown Miami, shut down I-95
- South Miami cop who bought booze for underage cadets gets probation
- Weather forecast: No snow in Miami. Unlike 40 years ago
- Dirt bike rider killed, 1 injured in local MLK Day crashes, 44 arrested
- Eight people shot during Martin Luther King Jr. celebration at Northwest Dade park
- After Ft Lauderdale airport shooting, Broward Sheriff Scott Israel in spotlight
- How developers are redesigning Miami, 9 acres at a time
- Former Miami Mayor Joe Carollo to run for brother’s commission seat
- Five dead, eight injured in shooting at Ft Lauderdale Intl Airport
- Police said man killed by cops had a gun, his family said he had his hands up
- Fired Miami cops joked about using black neighborhoods for target practice
- Sex, drugs and a big cop fight: Miami’s dirty laundry gets airing by besieged manager
- Miami Police to hold vote of no confidence in city manager
- Miami Police holiday video shows off dance moves, iconic spots
- Miami Police Academy cadets spruce up home for mother of fallen officer
- Miami Police turn investigation of missing guns over to state
- Miami New Times articles
- Talks to sell City of Miami’s riverfront HQ continue with commission approval
- Surveillance video shows man attacking Miami police officer at Magic City Casino
- Off-duty Miami police officer dies after crashing into home
- Miami Police knew for years that homicide evidence container was rotting
- Judge sentences woman to life in prison for killing police officer boyfriend
- Miami Police motorcycle officer killed in multi-car crash in southwest Miami-Dade
- Private information of South Florida police officers compromised by website
- Miami Police Officer Testifies in Whitey Bulger Trial
- S. Fla. officers killed in the line of duty since 1974